7 hours ago
2
The post 5 Tried And Tested Seafood Delivery Companies 2025 appeared first on Penny Pinchin' Mom.
Searching for a seafood delivery company that you can trust can be a tough find. There are so many out there that it can be easy to get lost in all of the ones that aren’t worth your time, leading you to give up altogether. But, we don’t want you to give up, which is why we’re here to help.
We’re going to be diving into some of the best options on the market right now so that you have a better idea of where you should be looking. Each and every option that we are going to present to you today has been tried and tested in 2025 to give you the most accurate list possible. So, if you’re ready, let’s get started.
Maine Lobster Now
Kicking things off with arguably the best in the business, Maine Lobster Now is a fishmonger headquartered in Maine, specializing in lobster! Though they specialize here and their lobster is to die for, it’s not the only thing on offer as you will find scallops, shrimp, crabs and so much more when you search their website.
The lobster though is absolutely to die for. If you want fresh lobster, and you are quite particular about what you do and do not like, then this is the place for you. With a focus on quality and freshness for all customers, you will never taste lobster quite like it.
What Do We Like The Most?
One of the things we like the most is that all of the lobsters are fully traceable and they are sustainable harvested. As well as this, the price isn’t too high considering the quality, and you get exactly what you want delivered directly from Maine’s coast to your doorstep in a fast, and efficient manner.
What Do We Dislike?
There have been known issues with shipping at times, but whether that’s down to weather delays or uncontrollable factors is unknown.
Citarella
Next up on the list we’re going to be talking about a company called Citarella. If you’re looking for top-quality seafood in the fresh fish market, you’re in the right place. Not only do they offer fish in the traditional sense for you to cook with, but they also offer pre-made chef specials that you can choose from. So, if you’re in the mood for a salmon burger or a swordfish kabob, or other products that are similar to this, you might find that this is the place for you.
Widely known as a strong contender on the market, you won’t find anything less than excellence when it comes to the seafood offered here.
What Do We Like The Most?
The wide variety of offerings really makes you feel like you are getting your money’s worth when you purchase. You also get the option for a one-off shop or a subscription based service, meaning that it’s suitable for everyone.
What Do We Dislike?
It’s a little more expensive than some of the other options, making it harder to justify for some items.
Pure Fish
If you want a convenient option, Pure Fish are there to deliver you just that. All of their seafood offerings are neatly portioned into trays so that when you receive them they are ready to go into the oven. There are a variety of cuts that you can choose from, and you can even add caviar as an option if you fancy some for your next meal or if you are having guests over.
What Do We Like The Most?
All products come pre-sealed in oven trays which is handy for those days you just want an easy life. Also, all of the fish is prepared thoroughly, ready to cook when you get them.
What Do We Dislike?
The portion sizes are slightly smaller than some of the other companies, meaning you may get less value for money.
Rastelli’s
Started in the 1970’s, Rastelli’s has been on the market for a long time, gaining valuable experience that has allowed them to cater to a large number of seafood lovers. They offer fresh, high-quality fish, which some people may find hard to believe seeing as they are not a dedicated fishmonger or seafood business like most of the others on this list. But, in some ways this just gives them a bit of an edge because they are able to offer what others can’t, catering to a larger audience.
What Do We Like The Most?
We love the fact that all of the seafood sold here is procured by companies that adhere to sustainable practices. Due to the nature of this business, you can also get some delicious fish and meat mixture boxes which is a huge bonus for some people.
What Do We Dislike?
The lack of selection when it comes to seafood is disappointing as the quality of what is on offer is so high. Customer service doesn’t seem to be the best.
Lobster Anywhere
Another option for the lobster lovers out there, Lobster Anywhere is able to give you exactly what you need. Providing high-quality, fresh lobster all over the US, you are guaranteed to love the products you receive. Just ensure that you order in the correct time frame, otherwise you might not get your lobster when you want it.
What Do We Like The Most?
There are daily catches on offer that are able to be shipped overnight to preserve the freshness. With both fresh and frozen options available, you shouldn’t struggle to find what you want.
What Do We Dislike?
They have pretty pricey products, and you have to order before 3pm to be able to get the overnight shipping.
So, there you have it then! Now you have a solid five options for you to research some more, and then get testing out the various options. Choose the one that you think is going to provide you with what you want more than the others, and if that one isn’t everything you hoped it would be, there is always another option waiting for you. But, each and every company that we have put forward to you today has been hand-selected because of their quality, and their dedication to their customers.
The post 5 Tried And Tested Seafood Delivery Companies 2025 appeared first on Penny Pinchin' Mom.
